2010
2009
2008
2007
88 | Very Good |
""Exhibits abundant aromas of earthy, berry fruit intermixed with black currants, tobacco leaf and spice. Enjoy this medium-bodied supple, seductive Cabernet over the next 7-10 years.""
Robert M. Parker, Jr.
The Wine Advocate - December 2010
88 | Very Good |
""Deep ruby. Medicinal blackberry and licorice on the nose. Densely packed and sweet on entry, then juicy and tight in the mid-palate, with dark berry and bitter chocolate flavors. The edgy tannins call for at least 12 to 18 months of patience.""
Stephen Tanzer
International Wine Cellar - June 2010
2006
87 | Very Good |
""Soft, round, possesses good berry fruit, seductive tannins...represents a very fine glass of Cabernet.""
Robert M. Parker, Jr.
The Wine Advocate - December 2008
88 | Very Good to Excellent |
""Dark berry, licorice and mint flavors joined by tobacco and graphite. Finishes with good lift and length.""
Stephen Tanzer
International Wine Cellar - June 2009
2005
90 | Outstanding |
""A beauty. Savory black currant fruit notes intermixed with some licorice, underbrush, and spice jump from the glass of this medium to full-bodied, smoothly textured, beautifully elegant wine.""
Robert M. Parker, Jr.
The Wine Advocate - December 2007
88-90 | Very Good to Excellent |
""Distinctly suave, sweet and fine-grained for this bottling, but still tight and penetrating, with lovely floral lift in a Medoc cabernet way.""
Stephen Tanzer
International Wine Cellar - June 2007
5 Stars |
""Vivid black fruits and minerals. Structured and elegant.""
Decanter - August 2008
2004
89 | Very Good |
""Exhibits peat moss, black currant, cedar and earth characteristics in its elegant personality. With sweet fruit, an opulent mid-palate, and admirable purity as well as length, it is a supple Cabernet.""
Robert M. Parker, Jr.
The Wine Advocate - December 2006
89 | Very Good to Excellent |
""Good ruby-red. Rich aromas of black cherry and menthol. Sweet, dense and lush for this bottling, with black cherry and cassis flavors.""
Stephen Tanzer
International Wine Cellar - June 2006
90 | Outstanding |
""Exhibits a dense ruby/purple color in addition to copious quantities of herbaceous-tinged cassis fruit, full body, ripe tannin, and a soft, plump personality.""
Robert M. Parker, Jr.
The Wine Advocate - December 2005
2002
90 | Outstanding |
""Offers sweet red and black currant fruit, along with notions of licorice, earth, and underbrush. Already drinkable, it promises to age nicely for 10-12 years.""
Robert M. Parker, Jr.
The Wine Advocate
89 | Very Good to Excellent |
""Sweet, expressive aromas of plum, currant, loam and tobacco. Supple and fat but dry, with good flavor intensity. Finishes with substantial broad, dusty tannins.""
Stephen Tanzer
International Wine Cellar
Exceptional |
""It has the rich, seamless density of a young Cos d'Estournel. The black extract offers fineness rather than rough edges, the finish lifted by peppery spice. Cleanly made, and ready for grilled sirloin; drink now or 2010-2012.""
Wine & Spirits
2001
89 | Very Good |
""Exhibits a more saturated ruby/purple color along with a big, dense bouquet of earth, licorice, black currants, and forest floor. Full-bodied and rich, it requires another 1-2 years of cellaring. It should last for 10-12 years, possibly longer.""
Robert M. Parker, Jr.
The Wine Advocate
3 Stars | Recommended |
""Classic and clean aroma. Well structured, with enough fruit to balance the huge grippy tannins and alcohol. Long, aromatic finish.""
Decanter
Recommended |
""Red plums and spice on the nose. Rounded, ripe, and dense with chocolaty tannins, and great texture.""
Sante
4 Stars |
""Attractive, intense and deep, promising block chocolate and cherries and nuts. A dense, vigorous young wine with firm acidity and well-judged tannin.""
The World of Fine Wine
2000
""Montelena’s 2000 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa exhibits plenty of sweet black currant fruit along with bright notes of black cherries, minerals and dried herbs. The addition of 25% Merlot from the estate’s vineyard softened the wine and gave it more texture as well as charm. It will be delicious upon release, and drink well for 10-12 years.""
Robert M. Parker, Jr.
The Wine Advocate
1999
""The sweet nose of black cherries and currants is followed by a medium-bodied red displaying notions of earth, licorice, tobacco, and spice. It is a supple-textured, delicious Cabernet to enjoy over the next 10-12 years.""
Robert M. Parker, Jr.
The Wine Advocate
4 Stars |
""Concentrated fruit with good complex flavors; drinks well now and can age 10 years.""
Beverage Dynamics
""Chateau Montelena has been a famed winery for decades; we found its Cabernet powerful and almost thick with fruit like a Cabernet from our youth. Explosive and memorable.""
Dorothy J. Gaiter and John Brecher
The Wall Street Journal
1998
""It exhibits a dark plum/purple color in addition to dense, sweet black currant aromas, soft tannin, and fat, creamy, cassis flavors with hints of tobacco, spice box, and dried herbs. Drink this delicious Cabernet over the next decade." "
Robert M. Parker, Jr.
The Wine Advocate
1997
1996
1995
1994
1993
1992
1991